Welcome to Bavellie’s Pizzeria
At Bavellie’s Pizzeria, located on Cherry Valley Road in Newark, Ohio, pizza is not just a meal; it’s a passion. Founded with a love for authentic flavors, Bavellie’s combines traditional recipes with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Their menu boasts a variety of mouthwatering options, from classic pizzas to savory subs and hearty salads, catering to every palate. Each dish, highlighted by the tantalizing wings and flavorful subs, promises a satisfying dining experience. Emphasizing takeout for your convenience, Bavellie’s Pizzeria invites you to indulge in a slice of comfort at home or on the go, making every bite worth savoring.
- 2066 Cherry Valley Rd Newark, OH 43055 United States Hotline: (740) 522-4563
Welcome to Bavellie’s Pizzeria, a gem nestled in Newark, Ohio, where the aroma of freshly baked pizza wafts through the air, beckoning food lovers from all around. Located at 2066 Cherry Valley Rd, this charming spot is a blissful retreat for those craving delicious pizza and hearty subs, all in a friendly atmosphere.
Bavellie’s Pizzeria is not just another pizzeria; it is a celebration of flavor and quality ingredients. The menu boasts an impressive selection of pizzas topped with vibrant, fresh ingredients that can satisfy any palate. From classic options to innovative creations, every pizza is crafted with care, ensuring a symphony of taste in every bite.
- Highlights of the Menu:
- Takeout Options: Perfect for busy days or cozy nights in, Bavellie’s offers convenient takeout so you can enjoy their delicious dishes wherever you are.
- Salads Galore: Start your meal off right with a variety of fresh salads. Whether you choose the Garden Salad or the Turkey Bacon Salad, each one is a delightful mix of crisp greens and savory toppings.
- Wings: Don't forget to try their wings—available in boneless or traditional styles. These flavorful bites are perfect for sharing (or not!) and come sauced to perfection.
- Subs to Savor: Their 8-inch subs are another highlight, featuring a variety of fillings such as the satisfying Meatball Sub and the tangy BBQ Chicken Sub.
Every visit to Bavellie’s Pizzeria feels like a special occasion. The inviting atmosphere makes it perfect for families, friends, or a casual date night. The staff is warm and welcoming, ensuring a pleasant experience from the moment you walk in.
As a food reviewer, my visits to Bavellie’s Pizzeria are always met with anticipation. The robust flavors, attentive service, and the sense of community make it more than just a place to eat—it’s an experience. So, if you find yourself in Newark, make sure to swing by Bavellie’s Pizzeria. Your taste buds will thank you!
For more information or to place an order, you can reach them at (740) 522-4563. Dive into the culinary delight that is Bavellie’s Pizzeria, and let every bite take you on a flavorful journey!

We had a pepperoni pizza and garlic bread DoorDashed to our hotel and were very happy with our choice! We loved the cheesy garlic bread and our pizza had tons of pepperoni!!!

Very good! Would eat again. Forgot my cheese on my salad but that can happen anywhere. I enjoyed their pizza.

Great pizza shop! We ordered takeout and pizza was good. The service was very good! It is thin crust pizza and tastes almost like Donatos Pizza. Overall pretty good.

Great pizza. Great service. It's just like the old mom and pop restaurants not commercial.

I've only ever had this through Grubhub delivery which normally would not be fair to judge off of however every time (15x+) everything I've ordered has been phenomenal. Their taco pizza, BBQ Chicken pizza, white pizza and Hawaiian are all delicious. Their salads are simple but always fresh and the breadsticks are fantastic! The order is always complete and they put out the food so quickly each and every time! Can't wait to make it into the restaurant at some point!

Always friendly and the best tasting pizzas and calzones Favorite is any of their specialty items

We happened to be in town so I did a quick yelp search and found this great little shop. We ordered the supreme and we were not disappointed. The crust was thin and crispy, the sauce was tangy with a touch of sweetness. Great toppings and came in a flash. What's not to like? Give it a try!

First visit was average. This place seems fine for a neighborhood pizza joint, but I'm not sure it's anything to write home about. Pros: quick pickup (15 mins), lots of pizza toppings, fresh salad veg Cons: super thin crust, not enough cheese or sauce